May
Okay, I’ve been a big fan and user of Facebook for a long time.
I have really enjoyed connecting with some amazing people in really personal and meaningful ways. I’ve reconnected with old friends from the past. I’ve been more involved in the day-to-day lives of my extended family. I’ve found friends who share my interests and weird perspectives on life. And I’ve learned from the experiences and opinions of my friends.
In short, I have enjoyed interacting in a community whose discussions happen to take place across cables rather than cafe tables. And Facebook has provided that place for us.
But, oh, how the place has changed since I first came to the neighborhood.
I, like many others, was drawn away from MySpace which at the time was becoming way too slimy and weird, with lots of porn spam and just the sense that everything was a little too much in the open. If MySpace was the Vegas Strip, then Facebook seemed to offer something a little more like Main Street where there was a simple private place to share time with friends. And Facebook grew enormously because so many of us felt we were connecting personally to real people who we know and care about (rather than getting messages from what was probably a middle-aged guy posing as a hot 19-year old girl…).
Sure, then came the games—Farmville, Mafia Wars, Scrabble—that wasted so much time, but that still could be like sitting around and playing a board game with your friends. And there were the countless remodelings that drove us all crazy (“Bring back the old Facebook!”). But still, at the heart of it Facebook was a place to connect with friends (and organizations and products) that mean something to us.
The heart of the problem with Facebook has been the incremental removal of all of the safety and privacy that was so crucial to its growth (Here’s a great interactive representation). I have repeatedly used the term “bait-and-switch” in referring to this process, but it may be more like the frog in the boiling water. The “switch” has been so gradual that many people don’t see it as a switch. It just seems natural. And that’s what Facebook would have us believe (as it’s in their best interest to be able to sell our information to the highest bidder). CEO Mark Zuckerberg (who’s all of 26) recently said “People have really gotten comfortable not only sharing more information and different kinds, but more openly and with more people. That social norm is just something that has evolved over time.” (As if Facebook hasn’t been actively moving the goal post the whole time.
Look, I have loads of information about me all over the web. There are sites and blogs and forums and comments that I have chosen to be public. I’m no Luddite sitting in a barn in the dark, alone in a corner. I believe in the power of public discourse and the need for more public interaction and engagement. I don’t hide my feelings about many topics and don’t shy away from discussions of difficult issues.
But then there are aspects of my life and my world that are only for certain eyes and ears. We all have many personas and we sometimes have aspects of our lives that we like to keep separate. (I teach young kids and there are certain things that I “like” that are perfectly appropriate for the adults in my life but which I prefer not to share with them.) Privacy isn’t an all or nothing operation (this great article has a quite a few good arguments about this…). I doubt that I know many people who would be comfortable with having either all OR none of their information public. We have different aspects of our life that we like to treat differently and that’s something that Facebook used to be good at doing.
Now, they want to let it all hang out. And not just on Facebook, across the rest of the internet. And now they allow their partners (makers of apps, quizzes, games and junk) to keep all the information about you that they want. And if I want to include my hometown (go Philly!) or school (Explorers!), I have to automatically link to a page and that information goes to everybody. (Now, obviously, I’ve already made those two facts public, but I don’t do so for everything that I “like”.)
So I’m very disillusioned with what Facebook is doing. I know they’re a business and I know they exist to make money. Again, I’d gladly pay a monthly fee to have the service as is but with real control over who sees what. But for now I’m going to take a big step back. I won’t delete my account just yet. I’ll deactivate it and wait and see.
The upside is that I’ll probably be posting here more often….
See also:
Top Ten Reasons You Should Quit Facebook
More Reasons Why You Should Still Quit Facebook
Farewell, Facebook
It all started when I bought a new phone a while back. I decided that the bulky Windows Media Smartphone that I had was just overkill. As much as I wanted this to be the tool that kept me organized and on top of things, it wasn’t. And I hated (hated!) the touch screen for the phone. It would turn off in the middle of a call and I had to switch back and forth between seeing the keypad and using other functions. And the screen would get oily from sitting against my face (you know it happens to your phone too…). And the thing was just big and bulky.
month. So I wanted a new MP3 player to download all that great music to have at my beck and call and I started looking.
The goal





